No.

Criteria content

Sen Viet Auction Partnership

Ben Thanh Auction Partnership

Chuoi Gia Tri Auction Partnership

I

Necessary facilities and equipment to secure the auction for the type of asset to be auctioned

18

23

20

1

Facilities to secure the auction

9

11

9

2

Necessary equipment to secure the auction

6

8

8

3

Having an active website

2

2

2

4

Having been approved by the competent authority to be eligible for the online auction form

0

1

0

5

Having a place to store auction records

1

1

1

II

The auction plan is feasible and effective

20

22

20

1

The auction plan proposes the auction organization is carried out in accordance with the provisions of law, ensuring publicity, transparency and objectivity

4

4

4

2

The auction plan proposes a time and place to sell, recieive auction participation documents, a place to hold the auction, and a price announcement meeting that is convenient for auction participants; Auction form, price step, number of auction rounds are feasible and highly effevtive

3

4

2

3

The auction plan proposes way to keep information confidential, prevent collusion, and lower prices

4

4

4

4

The auction plan proposes more locations, other public annnouncements to increase the dissemination of auction infomation

3

4

4

5

The auction plan proposes solutions to ensure safety, security and order for the organization of the acution

3

3

3

6

The auction plan proposes solutions to situations arising in the process of organizing the auction

3

3

3

III

Competence, experience and reputation of the auction organization

28

30

21

1

In the preceding year, have done auction service contracts that have been performer of the same type of property as the property expected to be auctioned

4

3

2

2

In the preceding year, have organized auctions successful that have been performer of the same type of property as the property expected to be auctioned with the average difference between the winning bid price and the staring price

10

10

0

3

The operation time in the field of auction be counted from the date of issuance of Establishment decision or the issuance of an operation registration certificate (The certificate of business registration for auction enterprices established before the effective date of the Property Auction Law)

4

5

5

4

Number of auctioneers of the auction organization

2

2

3

5

Practice experience of auctioneers of auction organizations (From the time of being granted auctioneer cards according to Decree No. 05/2005/ND-CP dated January 18th, 2005 of the Government on auctions property or register a list of auctioneers at the Department of Justice in accordance with the Government’s Decree No. 17/2010/ND-CP dated March 4th, 2010 on asset auctions or auctioneer cards under the Law on Property Auctions)

3

4

4

6

Pay Corporate income tax or contribute to the State budget in the preceding year, minus value-added tax

1

2

3

7

Staff working under labor contract

3

3

3

8

Having trainees practicing in asset auction organization in the year preceding or the year in which the application for registration for seletion is submited

1

1

1

IV

Remuneration for auction services and auction costs is appropriate

5

5

5

V

The auction organization’s ability to support sales

0

5

0

Total score

71

85

66